Everyone talks about whether the news is bullish or bearish. Why does the market still go in the opposite direction?

34 Answers
Default Recent
king of karaoke

The bullish and bearish news generally come out is just a simple comparison with the expected value. The real bullish and bearish are not what we can analyze. For example, the non-agricultural data may be lower than expected, but if the number is still large, That means that employment is still very strong, so this data is actually bullish. As a low-level trader, don’t analyze the data. What we look at is how the data affects the market.

5 Upvotes
18 Comments
Add
Original
cool breeze

If it is a retail investor who reads the news, especially a novice who reads the news and makes an order, he will die quickly. The news side is the data market. At that time, the market fluctuates greatly, so the profit will be large. On the contrary, if there is no good stop loss setting, the loss will be more. In fact, the news is for big institutions to read. They can get the data before 90% of the people in the market. Most people think that the news is profitable, long, bearish and short. They use this setup to cut leeks. There is a situation where all profits are turned into bad ones, and all bad ones are turned into long ones. Therefore, veterans do not do data market. Even if they participate, they still need to take a small position, and there must be a stop loss.

890 Upvotes
6 Comments
Add
Original
苏闻衫

In fact, the good and bad news you see released may not be the first-hand news, and you may have missed the real market.

And some bad news and good news are pure fart, some are fabricated by others to attract traffic attention, and some are news that has nothing to do with the market.

To be honest, will the real good and bad news be released for everyone to see? Even if it is accidentally leaked out and you find out, do you dare to stud it all in?


dachshund

397 Upvotes
5 Comments
Add
Original
mu qiannuo

The generally seen positive and negative are all on the Golden Ten data, the Golden Ten data comes from Reuters, and behind Reuters is Goldman Sachs.

The real source of data is the foreign central bank, and the official website of the foreign central bank has never had any expected value. And with its team of top economists across the country, if you want to predict, what is the probability of predicting such a large difference.

Psychologically speaking, only when there is hope in the heart will there be disappointment. The Golden Ten data (or Goldman Sachs) just gave you this expectation. There are a few retail investors who really understand the data. As for the purpose... If retail investors don't enter the market, whose money will institutions make?

879 Upvotes
4 Comments
Add
Original
blv0918

If you go to the news side, you will face two problems. The first is that you analyze the news that is good and bad. The second is that it is already very difficult to do the first step correctly. The market may not follow the news when the news is good or bad. That being the case, the news should be avoided, don't get involved, don't care

732 Upvotes
4 Comments
Add
Original
pied piper

On the eve of the U.S. market, the international gold may not be able to continue after its strength. The big frame has returned to the shock structure, and the road to rise is still bumpy. The current scattered trend has slightly disrupted our rhythm, but from the perspective of excluding the position, gold is still more inclined to be bearish, and the frame turns to shock does not mean to turn long

659 Upvotes
4 Comments
Add
Original
汇仁阁、ricky

You should understand what is the concept of buying facts based on expectations, time for space and other concepts. When big data comes, sometimes the market has already experienced a sharp rise or fall. When the data is actually released, the market will most likely go in the opposite direction. .

959 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
alchemy xiaoke

News is just a catalyst!

What we observe is the market changes after the news, and further decide what kind of trading strategy to use in the future.

It is more profitable, and it has risen, it should be.

Relatively high, more profits, no rise or fall, doubtful profits will be exhausted, easy to make a head.

Relatively low, bearish, not falling or rising, suspecting that the profit is exhausted, it is easy to build a bottom.

It's right to be negative and fall.

Smart technical analysts can even predict the trend after the news through pure technical analysis!

Because someone knows everything before you, and where you are, the corresponding news will naturally appear! And the market will move in the direction that those in the know want.

952 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
hui old monk

Specifically, it looks like this: Finance emphasizes expectations. When a certain financial data or event is determined to be announced at a certain point in time, the market will be affected by market expectations and emotions during a period of time before the announcement. Follow everyone’s expectations. When the data or events are announced at this point in time, as everyone expected, the news has been digested by the previous expectations, and the market has finished ahead of schedule, so it will go in the opposite direction after the announcement

865 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
pr25571286

All the positive process of information needs a period of time to spread, and the news has deteriorated in your hands, just like the most important buying point has been missed. The so-called good and bad can only be used as investment advice and cannot affect your own decision.

597 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
福汇林枫378824

In this market, some professionals or institutions will make some expectations before the market appears. When the probability of this expectation is high, they will enter the market in advance to make arrangements. After the market is announced, these institutions can compare the size of the data with the expected value. If there is not much difference, they will close the previously arranged orders. This is a typical fact of buying and selling in anticipation. Closing positions will impact the market order volume, etc. Generally, the market needs a certain period of time to digest, so it creates a situation that is different from the direction of the data!

568 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
berlin in the distant mountains

In this situation, generally speaking, sometimes the market has been digested in advance. Those who have been in contact with the market for 2-3 years must know it. Data vane!

500 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
诚信第一

The world is so big, and although some of the news we see is bullish, there are often other things that affect investors' judgment. It is normal to have the opposite situation, after all, you still need to control the position.

393 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
warren trading institute

Hello, the subject, foreign exchange market trading, personal advice, look for institutions in the K-line line to show their feet on the buying side, and capture trading opportunities!

The k-line is the most intuitive and has research value.

The news is of course important to us, but when we see a news, it has already been digested by Wall Street traders, so sometimes the news is just a flash, the bullish rises, the bearish falls or reverses!

For example, in the non-agricultural data on the evening of December 6, 2019, the market was negative. As a result, the gold market first rose to the 1480 line and finally fell to the 1460 line!

The above personal views are welcome to leave a message in the comment area!

On December 6th, through the technical analysis of the k-line, the gold price was placed below 1468-1473 with long orders, and above 1494-1483 with empty orders. The price hit the 1468-1473 range for the fifth time, and the price rebounded to 1480. The supply zone was blocked and fell!

292 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
缠中狩猎

It depends on whether the news exceeds expectations and whether it has been reacted in advance by the market. The more sudden the news, the better the effect will be. If you overdraw long kinetic energy, you must be careful about consistent turning points. In the second case, if the news is known to some people in advance and most people can expect it, then the news expectation will be reflected by the market in advance. Therefore, judging the impact of a news: mainly depends on the impact level of the news, whether it is sudden, whether it is continuous, and whether the current trend has reflected the trend. The most important point is to respond according to the real reaction of the market, and any prediction must be tested by the market.

190 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
wishful trend

Silly boy, the news is only a catalyst, that is, if it is consistent with the original trend, it can only accelerate the development of the market (remember only two words). If the direction is inconsistent, it will only affect the market fluctuations for a short time. This fluctuation is those who go short and go long after reading the news without thinking.

Besides, do you think the impact of the news is simply short-term more or less, rather than long-term impact? You think that a certain news will definitely make the market rise, but that is just your subjective interpretation or that of some people.

139 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
刘言金1

The news is only one aspect, and the price operation is not only based on the news, but also combined with the technical side.

682 Upvotes
2 Comments
Add
Original
姚胖说.

All the good things are empty, and all the good things are good.

673 Upvotes
2 Comments
Add
Original
sand sculpture

for example.

When you were young, you failed the exam. If your dad was in a good mood today, he wouldn't give you a belt stew, and would only say a few words about you.

When you were young, you got a score of 95 on the exam. If your dad was in a bad mood today, no matter how high you got in the exam, he would still find fault with you.

Those bulls and bears are just your wishful thinking. In trading, what you want to look at is the mood of the market, not your mood, understand?

560 Upvotes
2 Comments
Add
Original
荷花天使

guess

547 Upvotes
2 Comments
Add
Original

About

0

work

0

subscriber

About Us User AgreementPrivacy PolicyRisk DisclosurePartner Program AgreementCommunity Guidelines Help Center Feedback
App Store Android

Risk Disclosure

Trading in financial instruments involves high risks including the risk of losing some, or all, of your investment amount, and may not be suitable for all investors. Any opinions, chats, messages, news, research, analyses, prices, or other information contained on this Website are provided as general market information for educational and entertainment purposes only, and do not constitute investment advice. Opinions, market data, recommendations or any other content is subject to change at any time without notice. Trading.live shall not be liable for any loss or damage which may arise directly or indirectly from use of or reliance on such information.

© 2025 Tradinglive Limited. All Rights Reserved.