Where does your judgment come from when trading?

Sometimes we have to observe the unusual situation that is happening in the market, and then deal with the transaction order. The decision at this moment is very important. When encountering floating losses, should we cut the meat or carry the order? In the event of a reversal, should I enter the market in time or wait and see? There are more unexpected situations. When you encounter these unexpected situations, where does your judgment at the moment of making a choice come from? Can you be more specific?
View all 23 answers
有脾气的k线

This is indeed a question worth thinking about. I understand the judgment here as the basis for your trading behavior. Whether it is entering or exiting or waiting and watching, there must be a relatively fixed standard, what kind of action to make under what circumstances.

dachshund

Where does judgment come from?

First of all, I think the basis for your judgment needs to come from trading varieties. We all know that different trading varieties will have their own characteristics, and the influencing factors of each variety are different. The same event must have different effects on different species. For example, in the case of gold, gold itself has the attributes of a commodity, which exists in itself, and also has the attribute of hedging. If the conflict on the Korean peninsula escalates, it may be gold rather than the currencies of other countries that may be most affected. If, at this time, you hold a short position in gold, then you need to measure whether the news will affect your position as soon as the event comes out. The first thing to consider in trading is our trading variety.

Second, the structure of the trading market. Although the market is disorderly and irregular, it is difficult to know the precise highs and lows of the market. And the judgment of the trend will vary from person to person. No matter the point and trend are not fixed, they are always changing. Sticking to the rules can't save your trading, so probabilistic thinking and changing thinking are very important. Even so, I still think that the market will still have relative regularity under certain circumstances. For example, war incidents have increased the risk aversion sentiment of gold. This news will ultimately affect the people who view this incident. If everyone does not recognize this incident and remains unmoved, then the price will not rise. Since it is going to rise, it must rise with the appearance that it can be discovered. From A ---> B, the law of rising during the period can be found. This is also what I think of the market structure. Going back to the subject’s question, if I approve the price structure, I will have a basic judgment on the market, that is to say, as long as the structure I approve remains unchanged, the trend will not reverse, and I should hold it .

Third, judgment comes from your trading system. Trading still needs to return to the trading system. Don’t underestimate the concept of the trading system. It can be all-encompassing, not just simple trend, point and other judgments. It can be said that any kind of market behavior you can think of can be reflected in the system. I think a good trading system must be based on the present and imagine the future. What is the current price position, what kind of structure the future price may go out of, such a structure has appeared, what is your trading strategy, etc. You don’t need to write it out, but these precautions must be included in the within your system. All in all, everything is under control. (Try to think of everything you can think of, and you must have a logic of thinking. As for the black swan incident, there is no way. The things you can think of are not called black swans.)

dachshund

Finally, what I want to say is that judgment comes from your understanding of the market, your understanding of trading, etc. I personally suggest that you should think more about the trading system. As I mentioned before, what kind of trend will the market have, what is the standard for the establishment of the trend point, and what should be done. These things are all clear in your chest, I believe you will form the judgment in your subconscious.

Fear comes from the unknown of the future!

178 Upvotes
44 Comments
Add
Original
See more answers
好运来

I used to be obsessed with how to judge reversals or pullbacks, so that I can catch the trend in advance and make strategic adjustments. But with these years of trading, I found that the trend does not talk about the top and the bottom. The market price is a process of generation. Almost all participants take one step at a time. There is no preset ending. The market itself is a complex system , the predictability is very low. Let’s take the simplest non-agricultural data as an example. You can see that before the monthly non-agricultural data comes out, there are always so many people making predictions. Slap in the face. Therefore, in the face of reversals, my cognition is not about how to judge, but how to deal with this "unable to judge" dilemma, because in most cases we cannot judge, and sometimes your judgment is actually wrong Yeah...my take on reversals is that it's nothing more than an evolution from a swing, a reversal is an excessive pullback. Here are some of my favorite strategies:

1. Either regard all shock adjustments as reversals, unless it is finally proved that they are only callbacks, that is to say, as long as you think that there will be adjustments, you will close your positions and wait and see. Unless there are new signals that can prove the continuation of the trend, otherwise do not Will re-enter.

2. Treat all shock adjustments as pullbacks unless they turn out to be reversals. As long as you enter and adjust and hold on, unless a clear trend reversal signal is issued, you will never leave the market, and you will not backhand.

3. As long as you enter the consolidation state, regardless of whether the consolidation proves to be a transitional stage of a callback or a reversal in the end, you should reduce your position. After reducing your position, wait and see what happens. If it continues to rise, increase your position. If it continues to fall, close your position.

I hope it will be of some help to the landlord.

983 Upvotes
2 Comments
Add
Original
一路向北

This involves your own trading system. Let me briefly talk about where your opening position or so-called trading judgment comes from? I adopt a multi-variety trading strategy, and this is how I understand the direction.

Periodic resonance: the daily line, the fifteen-minute line, and the three-minute line fluctuate in one direction at the same time, and the power is often the largest. Of course, these resonances must require conditions.

First, the position of the variety must break through the new highs and new lows of the daily line and enter a new range.

Second, the operating variety must be a variety with relatively large fluctuations, such as gold, silver, Europe, America, etc.

Third, the strategy adopted must be pre-emptive strikes, breakthroughs to new highs and new lows should be followed up in time, and the opportunity must not be delayed, rapid response is required to control it

The trend is the direction, and the direction is the trend. If you follow the trend, you will have a better chance of winning!

861 Upvotes
3 Comments
Add
Original
View all 23 answers

About

0

work

0

subscriber

About Us User AgreementPrivacy PolicyRisk DisclosurePartner Program AgreementCommunity Guidelines Help Center Feedback
App Store Android

Risk Disclosure

Trading in financial instruments involves high risks including the risk of losing some, or all, of your investment amount, and may not be suitable for all investors. Any opinions, chats, messages, news, research, analyses, prices, or other information contained on this Website are provided as general market information for educational and entertainment purposes only, and do not constitute investment advice. Opinions, market data, recommendations or any other content is subject to change at any time without notice. Trading.live shall not be liable for any loss or damage which may arise directly or indirectly from use of or reliance on such information.

© 2026 Tradinglive Limited. All Rights Reserved.